The Spirit

Art in the movies is liable to take the strangest forms.

When an comic book artist’s artist like Will Eisner gets his best known creation made into a movie by a popular modern comic book artist like Frank Miller, what is the result?

Well, as one would expect, a few very beautiful visual movie moments. In between them, unfortunately, are a whole lot of words. Words, words, words. While we’ve all seen movies where the hero mocks the villain for boring him during a villainous diatribe, “The Spirit” is one of the first movies to use such a line where the writer of that line wasn’t paying attention to his own words. The words in “The Spirit” never seem to end, and wind up dragging the movie down when it should have been light, lean, and fast-moving . . . sort of like a Frank Miller comic book.

Frank Miller the comic book artist is been known for his stark, simple comic book tales like The Dark Knight, Sin City, and 300. And while some great movies have been made out of those works by others, “The Spirit” is Miller’s first movie as writer and director. And Frank Miller the movie writer and director seemed to forget all about what made Frank Miller the comic book writer and artist so popular to begin with. Perhaps he was trying too hard to capture Eisner’s quirky comic hero. Perhaps he went word-crazy because he didn’t have to draw all of the results. Whatever the cause, the result is not a good thing.

Samuel L. Jackson, stalwart veteran of movie disasters past, is watchable enough. Eva Mendes is lovingly showcased as beauty Sand Serif. Of course, while girl-watchers get treated to Mendes, Sarah Paulsen, Stana Katic, Paz Vega, Jaime King, and other femme fatales, they also have to suffer Scarlett Johansson fashion-nerded up to near unrecognizability. And then there’s Gabriel Macht, the hero of the film, who one can’t help but wonder how great he might have been in a better movie.

The result of a wonderful cast and a oddball visually-oriented director is more of a movie curiosity than an actual great movie experience. One can imagine an entire film class based around what was done right and done wrong on this movie, for as any good student of Sherlock Holmes knows, life is a series of lessons.

And “The Spirit” is definitely a lesson in something. Still not sure what, but something.

What great-grandfather Sherlock might have said about the film:
“Did you personally examine this ticket?”

Back to SherlockPeoria front page

Past Investigations

An Introduction to
Mr. Sherlock Holmes IV

The Spirit

Yes Man



Quantum of Solace

Role Models

Zack and Miri Make a Porno

Sex Drive

Nick and Norah’s Ultimate Playlist

Eagle Eye

Ghost Town

Burn After Reading

Bangkok Dangerous

The House Bunny

Tropic Thunder

Pineapple Express

Step Brothers

Mamma Mia!

Hellboy II: The Golden Army



The Incredible Hulk

You Don't Mess With The Zohan

Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull

Speed Racer

Iron Man

Harold And Kumar Escape From Guantanamo Bay

The Forbidden Kingdom

Miss Pettigrew Lives For A Day

Superhero Movie

Drillbit Taylor

The Bank Job


Be Kind, Rewind


Definitely, Maybe

The Bucket List


In The Name Of The King:
A Dungeon Siege Tale


Walk Hard

I Am Legend

Tin Man

August Rush


Hitman/No Country For Old Men


Au Pair II

Bee Movie

Gone Baby Gone

The Comebacks

The Brave One

Resident Evil: Extinction

3:10 to Yuma

Shoot 'Em Up




The Bourne Ultimatum

The Simpsons Movie

You Kill Me


Live Free or Die Hard


D.O.A.: Dead or Alive

Fantastic Four:
Rise of the Silver Surfer

Surf's Up

Mr. Brooks

Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End

Shrek The Third

Delta Farce

Spiderman 3


State of Fear – World War Z


Blades of Glory


Wild Hogs

The Shooter


Black Snake Moan

A Bridge to Terrabithia

Reno 911!:Miami

Music and Lyrics